Cheryl Craigie’s “What’s Going On” bears the delicate responsibility of revisiting a song already etched into the cultural consciousness. The song, made famous by Marvin Gaye, has remained popular because its core questions never went away. Why are people hurting? Why does the division continue? How do we cultivate compassion when the world seems determined to tear us apart? It is her ninth release, and Craigie’s take on the questions does not attempt to compete with the original but rather respectfully enters into its emotional landscape and lets its message come through her voice. The result is a performance that sounds reverent but not like a museum piece, familiar but not redundant. It is quietly moving to hear a contemporary independent singer-songwriter return to such an iconic plea for understanding and find that its emotional urgency remains remarkably intact. Craigie has made her career comfortably straddling folk, country, rock, pop, and Christian music, but she has always placed storytelling at the center of her work in those various styles. That instinct works beautifully here. Overall, then, “What’s Going On” is a song about human beings trying to make sense of suffering, and Craigie treats it not so much as a historical artifact but as a living conversation that still demands an answer. She doesn’t radically retool the classic but wisely foregrounds its message, leaving its emotional DNA recognizable while making room for her point of view. Her reading is like an artist jumping into an ongoing conversation about compassion and saying, in her own inimitable voice, that the conversation still matters.
It is, in the arrangement, that Craigie’s interpretation begins to carve out its identity, creating a musical soundscape where the words and the emotional message are kept squarely in the foreground. The rhythm has a hard-hitting but steady pulse, giving the recording forward movement without the excessive intensity that might detract from the song’s reflective character. Against this backdrop, warm and relaxing melodies unfold, creating a fascinating tension between the heaviness of the subject and the calmness of the musical setting. Rich strings slowly come into play, adding layers of tenderness and melancholy as the arrangement expands, while layered backing vocals eventually rise behind Craigie and impart the performance an increasingly communal feeling. And that feels particularly right because “What’s Going On” has always felt bigger than the person singing it. Its message is addressed to families, communities, strangers, and finally to society itself. Craigie’s arrangement has that dimension. The song begins with a sense of intimacy and develops into something more collective, as if something personal is becoming a collective plea for empathy. Craigie’s decision to do all the vocals and instruments herself adds another level of authenticity to the recording, making it feel personal and hands-on, rather than manufactured. It’s produced by longtime collaborator Eric Goldberg and polished through Lenny Delorey’s crisp mix, which hits a satisfying blend of modern clarity and organic warmth. The song has enough production detail to sound fresh, but none of it gets in the way of what the song is trying to do. Strings, rhythm, harmonies, and vocal layers all dovetail like pieces of an emotional architecture, providing Craigie with plenty of space to deliver a message that doesn’t require any unnecessary embellishment.
Craigie’s thick, expressive voice anchors all of these elements and provides this version’s emotional identity. Here her greatest strength is her sincerity. She doesn’t try to imitate Marvin Gaye’s idiosyncratic phrasing or to recreate his precise emotional blueprint; she treats the lyrics like the words of an artist who has a personal investment in what they’re saying. It’s that distinction that makes the performance feel real. “Mother, Mother, there are too many of you crying” is a familiar line that hits with the weight of a statement written for the here and now. The line has its historical associations, but Craigie’s delivery brings it into today, reminding listeners that grief, conflict, uncertainty, and the need for compassion are painfully familiar. Her take on “You know we’ve got to find a way to bring some lovin’ here today” is also affecting, as it does not overplay the sentiment. When the words carry such significant emotional weight, there is no need for extravagant vocal acrobatics. She holds herself back, making the request sound almost conversational and believable. She seems to know that this song is best when it feels like communication, not performance. Emotional honesty is all the more powerful when the backing harmonies converge around her, reinforcing the collective spirit at the core of the composition. Craigie’s versatility as an independent singer-songwriter—in folk, country, rock, pop, and Christian music—has clearly taught her the value of storytelling, and here every musical decision serves the story. The voice stays warm and humble, controlled yet emotionally engaged. The result is a performance that makes listeners want to remember the song and reconsider what the words mean to them in their own lives.
In the end, Cheryl Craigie’s “What’s Going On” works because it understands that some songs don’t need to be totally reworked; they just need to be heard again. Her reading pays tribute to Marvin Gaye’s enduring masterpiece but also provides another modern voice to its message, and she does so with warmth, restraint, and true belief. The recording is well arranged, but not overproduced. It is emotionally rich, but not melodramatic. It is respectful of its source but does not disappear into its shadow. The steady beat grounds the song, the strings add a further depth to the atmosphere, and the soaring harmonies gradually broaden the emotional spectrum of the piece until the performance feels almost like a congregation of voices around one simple but urgent query. Craigie’s choice to do the vocals and instrumentation herself makes the recording feel especially intimate, while Goldberg’s production and Delorey’s polished mix ensure that each layer is clear and purposeful. But most important, the performance preserves the timeless heart of “What’s Going On”: the knowledge that underneath arguments, divisions, fear, and suffering are human beings who still need each other. Craigie doesn’t claim that a song can solve the world’s problems; she doesn’t turn the recording into a lecture. Instead, she offers something softer and perhaps more lasting—a reminder to listen, to care, and to resist our numbness to pain around us. Decades after Marvin Gaye first posed his unforgettable question, Craigie shows why it still deserves an answer. Her version leaves the listener with the same basic truth that led her to record in the first place: understanding matters, compassion matters, and finding a way to bring more love into this world is still worth singing about.
For more information, follow Cheryl Craigie
TWITTER – SPOTIFY – SOUNDCLOUD – YOUTUBE
